M
Markus
Guest
Yes, he tells about many success stories, I think he is an excellent Dr. I love his youtube video as well.
-
Alan has completed the new Pain Recovery Program. To read or share it, use this updated link: https://www.tmswiki.org/forum/painrecovery/
-
Welcome to the new TMS Wiki server! Things aren't finished yet: email is not set up, so notification and password-reset emails don't go out, and new registrations are paused until email is installed. Details and updates are in this thread (click here). Locked out? Email tmswikisignups@gmail.com from the address where you receive TMS Wiki notifications.
Differences in approach between Sarno and Clarke (?)
- Thread starter Gigalos
- Start date
Gigalos
Beloved Grand Eagle
Thank you all very much for your input. For the time being I think I can only conclude that Clarke and Sarno might have some different views, but in the end both agree on the importance of the mind when it comes to certain physical symptoms. Work on the mind and feel better, both mentally and physically...
[This post has been edited so that it stays on the topic of the thread, which is comparison of Clarke's and Sarno's views.]
My complaint is that Clarke does NOT understand that much of what Sarno advocates, and therefore, should NOT be criticizing him publicly until he has read up sufficiently on Sarno. I've read all four of Sarno's books, and I immediately saw from your post that Clarke was making some educated guesses about what Sarno believes, statements that were inconsistent with what Sarno has actually WRITTEN. I stand by the criticisms I wrote earlier.
[I don't have] any problem whatsoever with you or others using Clarke's protocol. I absolutely LOVE the idea of more doctors criticizing the conventional health care system for largely ignoring emotional issues. My complaint was that Clarke is criticizing a man whose work he doesn't even know that well, and that is WRONG.
My complaint is that Clarke does NOT understand that much of what Sarno advocates, and therefore, should NOT be criticizing him publicly until he has read up sufficiently on Sarno. I've read all four of Sarno's books, and I immediately saw from your post that Clarke was making some educated guesses about what Sarno believes, statements that were inconsistent with what Sarno has actually WRITTEN. I stand by the criticisms I wrote earlier.
[I don't have] any problem whatsoever with you or others using Clarke's protocol. I absolutely LOVE the idea of more doctors criticizing the conventional health care system for largely ignoring emotional issues. My complaint was that Clarke is criticizing a man whose work he doesn't even know that well, and that is WRONG.
Last edited by a moderator:
Forest
Beloved Grand Eagle
Hi everyone,
This thread has gone downhill, so henceforth I'm going to institute a policy for this thread where all "interpersonal" content will be deleted. Interpersonal content is defined as content about another person who has posted in the thread. It includes but is not limited to content about other member's behavior and character.
No drama here please. Even if you discipline yourself and show restraint. Eventually it all goes downhill and drama is not what this forum is about.
The topic of this thread is "differences in approach between Sarno and Clarke." Thank you for keeping it on topic.
This thread has gone downhill, so henceforth I'm going to institute a policy for this thread where all "interpersonal" content will be deleted. Interpersonal content is defined as content about another person who has posted in the thread. It includes but is not limited to content about other member's behavior and character.
No drama here please. Even if you discipline yourself and show restraint. Eventually it all goes downhill and drama is not what this forum is about.
The topic of this thread is "differences in approach between Sarno and Clarke." Thank you for keeping it on topic.
Last edited: