Dr. Hanscom's Blog Never Give Up

Hi Dr. Hanscom,

It’s Donna, a former patient. I just wanted to write and tell you some good news regarding my back situation. You were right about forgiveness as well as the emotional aspects of back pain–at least in my case.

After following the physiological recommendations and taking the various classes you suggested, I read your book and began my own journey of forgiveness with the help of my church.

I continued to get stronger and feel better as I progressed through the various stages. However, the nerve pain continued to remain. It would crop up for no apparent reason and take me out. The final step to my healing process was a worship night at my church and prayers of healing. I was able to release all the guilt and shame I had been holding onto unbeknownst to me. I had received prayers, love and unconditional acceptance in return from the prayer team.

With all that said, the bottom line is, I am out of pain!! It has attempted to return but I am able to pray it away and remind myself of the healing that took place and it goes away. There is a huge element of emotional healing involved, as you have stated. I thought you might be interested in hearing another success story.

Thank you again for all of your insight, wisdom and help! It is truly amazing to wake up pain free!

Gratefully Yours,

Donna



Meet Donna C.

Imagine getting a letter like this from a patient you had worked with for a couple of years and then lost touch with after she moved away. Her success story is enough to write about in and of itself; but her case also changed the way I think about chronic pain.

Donna was an extremely pleasant, positive, and physically fit aerobics instructor and single mother of three teenagers. She came to me for a second opinion regarding a proposed spine fusion. It was going to be her sixth spine operation in seven years. She began to experience lower back pain (LBP) around the year 2000, without any obvious inciting event.

Before coming to see me, she had undergone the following procedures:

2002 Two-level lumbar spine fusion from L4 to S1, with marginal results

2003 Spinal hardware removed

• L5-S1 (lowest level) had not healed
• Weak area repaired, but it did not help

​

2007 Neurostimulator placed into spine (two trials placed), which helped for about a year

When she first came to see me in 2009, Donna was unable to work because of the following condition:

• Disabling LBP and leg pain
• L5-S1 fusion still had not healed
• Arthritic facet joints (joints along the back of the spinal column that link the vertebrae)
• Lumbar 3-4 disc, just above the two-level lumbar 4 to the sacrum fusion broken down to the extent that the vertebrae were “bone on bone” (However, her spine was stable at this level in that the vertebrae did not move when she leaned forwards and backwards, and there were no pinched nerves.)

​

Donna’s Journey

Because her condition was stable, and because there is little if any correlation between degenerative disc disease and back pain, I recommended no more surgery for her. As bad as her L3-4 disc looked, I did not feel it was the source of her pain. Besides, if L3-4 was fused, there was a strong chance she would not improve—L2-3 could break down quickly; and over five or ten years she might need a fusion up to her thoracic spine. With a fusion that high, you can no longer twist; and Donna was, after all, an aerobics instructor, and needed that flexibility.



Instead, I suggested that Donna apply the treatment outlined in the DOC process, and I referred her to a non-operative physician to help her along. She took my advice and aggressively pursued every part of the DOC program. She addressed sleep and stress, avoided pain medications, attended wellness classes, and resumed workouts at the gym. She consciously chose to move forward with her life in spite of her pain.

But she did not improve very much. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a patient work so hard at getting better with so little improvement. Because of her spine pathology, I still questioned whether I should offer her more surgery; but by that time she had decided to recover without any more surgical procedures. After a couple of years she moved to another state, and we lost touch.

Then, a couple of years later, around 2011, her letter came. At the time I was surprised at her degree of pain relief. But today I have seen this level of recovery occur consistently in many patients who fully engage the DOC process. In my experience, the most consistent predictor of success has been truly letting go of anger, including that caused by the chronic pain experience. True forgiveness is not just an intellectual exercise. While I have seen many patients improve before they let all the anger go, none become pain-free until they cross that line. I call it the “Continental Divide” of chronic pain. Remember, although you have legitimate and understandable reasons for your frustrations, your anger will still hurt you.

Today and what I have learned

Today I am more aware of the mind-body connection than I was when I first saw Donna eight years ago. I now regard emotional pain and physical pain as equivalent, in that they are processed in a similar part of the brain and with the same chemical responses. It appears that anxiety is the pain. As anxiety-produced adrenaline drops, nerve conduction slows down, and you feel less physical pain. Knowing this today, I can understand outcomes for patients like Donna, who became pain-free without additional surgery, even with her significant spine pathology. Her case also taught me:

1. Patience is critical for both physician and patient. I had given up—not on Donna but on the idea that the DOC concepts were going to help her. I learned that I can never predict who will respond or when the tools will kick in.
2. No matter where the pain originates or how severe the pathology might appear, relief is possible, if not probable, without surgery. That is not to say that the DOC process is 100% successful, nor do I feel that I have discovered a magic program. But I feel that the structure it imposes does allow patients to organize their thinking so as to connect with their own capacity to heal.
3. A caring community is powerful. Most patients in chronic pain isolate themselves, giving them more time to think about their pain, allowing the pain pathways to become deeply imbedded. Reconnecting with family, friends and society is a significant factor in moving away from pain pathways.

The final stage of the DOC process is “Expanding Your Consciousness.” The ultimate solution for solving pain is regaining your life perspective, regardless of the form it takes.

Never give up–ever!







Related posts:

1. Never Give Up – Breaking Through After Six Years
2. It Really is Upside Down
3. Out of the Abyss with Forgiveness

 

I know we all respect this doctor, but why would he publish the same story with 2 different names of the same patient ? Hopefully it was just to protect the patient's confidentiality. Tell me Dr. H. that this is a true case history of someone that healed after having multiple surgeries following the DOC Program.....The 1st story "Never Give Up" scrolls down to related stories to "Out of the Abyss with Forgiveness" .

Hi Dr. Hanscom,

It’s Beverly, a former patient. I just wanted to write and tell you some good news regarding my back situation. You were right about forgiveness as well as the emotional aspects of back pain–at least in my case.After following the physiological recommendations and taking the various classes you suggested at Swedish, I read your book and began my own journey of forgiveness with the help of my church.

I continued to get stronger and feel better as I progressed through the various stages. However, the nerve pain continued to remain. It would crop up for no apparent reason and take me out. The final step to my healing process was a worship night at my church and prayers of healing. I was able to release all the guilt and shame I had been holding onto unbeknownst to me. I had received prayers, love and unconditional acceptance in return from the prayer team.

With all that said, the bottom line is, I am out of pain!! It has attempted to return but I am able to pray it away and remind myself of the healing that took place and it goes away. There is a huge element of emotional healing involved, as you have stated. I thought you might be interested in hearing another success story. Thank you again for all of your insight, wisdom and help! It is truly amazing to wake up pain free!

Gratefully Yours,

Bev

MY PERSPECTIVE

Bev was an extremely pleasant and motivated aerobics instructor who came to me for a second opinion regarding a proposed spine fusion. It was going to be her sixth spine operation in seven years. She began to experience LBP around 2000 without an obvious inciting event. She underwent the following procedures:

• Two-level lumbar spine fusion from L4 to S1
  • Marginal results
• Spinal hardware removed
  • L5-S1 non-union was found. Although they re-grafted the weak area she was not re-instrumented
• Neurostimulator placed into her spine (two trials placed)
  • Helped for about a year
• Saw me with the following problems
  • Disabling LBP and some leg pain
    • Could not work
    • Single mother for three teenagers
  • The L5-S1 fusion still had not healed
  • L3-4 just above the L4-5 fusion was completely broken down
    • The disc was destroyed so the vertebrae were “bone on bone”
    • Her facets joints were arthritic
    • She was stable in that her vertebrae at this level did not move when she leaned forwards and backwards
      • There also no pinched nerves

My assessment and recommendations:

• No more surgery
  • She was stable
  • There is little if any correlation between degenerative disc disease and back pain
  • If L3-4 was fused, there was a high chance she would not improve—L2-3 could break down quickly and over 5-10 years she might be fused up into her thoracic spine
    • She is an aerobics instructor. With a fusion that high you can no longer twist.
• Pursue the treatments outlined in the DOC protocol
• Referred her to a non-operative physician to help her along

What happened?

• She pursued every part of the protocol aggressively.
  • She addressed sleep and stress
  • She did not want to use pain medications
  • She attended some of the wellness classes
  • She re-engaged in working out at the gym
  • She chose to move forward with her life in spite of her pain
• She initially did not improve very much and moved to another state
  • I don’t think I have seen another patient work so hard at getting better with so little improvement.
• Her spine pathology was severe enough that I still had some questions in my mind whether I should offer her more surgery. She by this time had ruled that option out.

I received her letter a couple of years later. I had lost track of her and was surprised at her degree of pain relief. Her spine was very degenerated. However, I have seen this degree of pain relief occur in many patients that have deeply engaged in learning tools to heal. The most consistent predictor of success is letting go of the anger engendered by the chronic pain experience. True forgiveness is not an intellectual exercise. I have seen few patients really improve before they cross this hurdle. I call it the “Continental Divide” of chronic pain.



Remember you have legitimate and understandable reasons for your frustrations. Anger will still destroy you.

 

I for one certainly hope Dr. Hanscom s blogs are for real. Surely he wouldn’t make this up - would he??

 

I hope not, but I believe there are ppl out there who would say anything just to make a buck

 

Oh yes now I see your response. Thanks. That clears things up.

 

One could ask him?

 

Sorry Jan...