Is vitiligo TMS?

renata doler

New Member
Hi everyone,
Does anyone know if vitiligo - a skin condition characterized by patches of the skin losing their pigment - is TMS? This is for our 18 year old neighbour boy who was diagnosed with vitiligo this spring.
 
Last edited:
My sister has this and it's auto immune. She has Hashimotos Thyroiditis. It's not tms but stress could probably exacerbate it. It really sucks because there's no good treatment for it and you have to stay out of the sun. I feel bad for him since he is so young too.
 
I can’t pretend to know everything about vitiligo, but this intrigues me:
I recently attended the first international symposium on vitiligo in Rome, Italy, where many vitiligo experts came together to discuss our research in vitiligo, as well as what we should focus on next. Dr. Richard Spritz, who has done wonderful work on the genetics of vitiligo, said that he was frustrated that papers published on vitiligo still start with, “The cause of vitiligo is unknown. There are many hypotheses as to the true cause. . .”. He finds this frustrating because we know SO MUCH about what causes vitiligo. I then got up to the podium and agreed, saying that whoever writes those sentences must have missed all of the papers that have been published in the past 30 years.

In fact, we know more about what causes vitiligo than any other autoimmune disease, including diabetes, thyroiditis, lupus, and others. It’s true that there have been many different ideas in the past about what causes vitiligo, from autoimmunity to cellular stress, chemicals, nerves, and genetics. And many scientists have spent a long time arguing about which one was correct. It turns out that most of them are correct, and work together to cause the clinical disease we call vitiligo. Have you ever heard the story about the blind men and the elephant? It describes a situation in which 3 blind men stumble upon an elephant and attempt to determine what it is, simply by touching it. One at the trunk believes it is a snake, another at the tusk claims it is a piece of rock, and the third at the leg argues that it is a pillar. At first they argue vehemently, but once they discuss and move around to examine it from the others’ perspectives, they collaborate to realize that each of them was correct in describing part of the whole, and that together they could discover the bigger truth.
Personally, I would not treat this condition as TMS/the mind-body connection. It is clear that it is not; note that the full article linked below does not really give any credence to the nerves and emotional stress hypothesis. However, perhaps the management of one’s mental health could be factored into a comprehensive plan for vitiligo that addresses the other components of the condition.

SOURCE: https://www.umassmed.edu/vitiligo/blog/blog-posts1/2017/01/answer-to-what-causes-vitiligo/ (What causes vitiligo? - UMass Vitiligo Clinic & Research Center)
 
I can’t pretend to know everything about vitiligo, but this intrigues me:

Personally, I would not treat this condition as TMS/the mind-body connection. It is clear that it is not; note that the full article linked below does not really give any credence to the nerves and emotional stress hypothesis. However, perhaps the management of one’s mental health could be factored into a comprehensive plan for vitiligo that addresses the other components of the condition.

SOURCE: https://www.umassmed.edu/vitiligo/blog/blog-posts1/2017/01/answer-to-what-causes-vitiligo/ (What causes vitiligo? - UMass Vitiligo Clinic & Research Center)

Thank you so much for your response, I am sure it will help the family. I was kind of hoping it was TMS because it would mean he could be cured. But still he could probably benefit at least partially from many aspects of TMS treatment techniques and approach to managing emotional and mental health.
 
My sister has this and it's auto immune. She has Hashimotos Thyroiditis. It's not tms but stress could probably exacerbate it. It really sucks because there's no good treatment for it and you have to stay out of the sun. I feel bad for him since he is so young too.

Thank you so much for your kind response, I really appreciate it. I feel so bad for the boy.
 
Thank you so much for your response, I am sure it will help the family. I was kind of hoping it was TMS because it would mean he could be cured. But still he could probably benefit at least partially from many aspects of TMS treatment techniques and approach to managing emotional and mental health.
As Miffy pointed out, I also suspect that significant stress can exacerbate many structural conditions; extreme stress alone is enough to age our bodies more quickly, break down our immune systems and other bodily processes, etc. It’s also undeniable that emotions can make it more difficult to accept life with a structural condition, so it’s really a two-prong issue. I think it’s beneficial for everyone who has any structural condition to make sure their mental health is being addressed for these reasons.

(And people without structural conditions should of course work on mental health management as well; Jan on this forum frequently references Dr. Gabor Mate’s book, When the Body Says No, frequently.)
 
Back
Top