Involuntary Finger Curling While Playing Bass – Could This Be TMS?

mishabass

Newcomer
Hi everyone,

I'm a bass guitarist with about 14 years of playing experience, and I'm dealing with something that's been extremely frustrating.

Whenever I play fingerstyle, my middle finger involuntarily tenses up and curls toward my palm, especially when I pluck a string with my index finger. The curling happens regardless of how hard I try to prevent it.

Interestingly, this doesn't happen when I play with a pick, and my finger functions normally during everyday activities. When I pluck using only my middle finger, the curling is less pronounced. I can also do the alternate index and middle finger plucking motion in the air just fine.

I've successfully overcome TMS symptoms in the past, including problems with my fretting hand, knees, and stomach. Because of those experiences, I'm wondering whether this could be another manifestation of TMS, even though the symptoms resemble musician's focal dystonia.

I'm particularly interested in hearing from anyone who has experienced involuntary finger curling, muscle tension, or similar movement problems while playing an instrument.

Has anyone dealt with something like this and successfully recovered? If so, what helped you? I have started journaling and doing my best to just "play" but this has been the most stubborn case I ever had and becoming so difficult that I can barely play. It has lasted 3 months.

I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences. My goal is to regain normal fingerstyle playing without the involuntary curling.

Thanks, everyone!
 
Hi @mishabass welcomea
I'm wondering whether this could be another manifestation of TMS

I think it could be mind-body and the neuroplasticity of your brain could help you overcome it.

I say this because many years ago I did some voluntary front-of-office work for a health charity for musicians and other performers. During my time there I learned that musicians dealing with the kind of thing you describe have found the Feldenkrais Method really helpful for retraining the nervous system. Because Feldenkrais isn't about "stretching" or forcing posture, it targets the brain-to-hand loop that can cause the curling.

I asked AI to help me describe how Feldenkrais works using the example of what you describe is happening to you and it came up with this (all of the following that's in italics)...
  • Bypassing the Sensory Trigger: Since your finger only curls when triggered by the specific feel and resistance of the bass string, Feldenkrais uses gentle, unfamiliar variations to break the automatic reflex. For example, exploring how your hand responds if you change your wrist angle, rest your thumb somewhere completely new, play with a thin cotton glove or tape on your fingertips to change the tactile feedback, or play in a totally unfamiliar position.
  • De-linking the Fingers Without Force: Instead of drilling through the curl (which just reinforces the neural pathway), Feldenkrais uses slow, tiny, non-habitual movements—often away from the instrument at first—to help your brain clearly map out where the index finger's job ends and the middle finger's begins.
  • Connecting the Hand to the Rest of the Body: When a finger starts misfiring, we naturally tense up our forearm, shoulder, and jaw to compensate. Feldenkrais looks at how your fingers connect through your wrist, elbow, shoulder blade, and ribs so the larger muscles support your arm and your hand doesn't feel like it has to over-grip.
If you decide to look into it, try to find a Feldenkrais practitioner who has experience working with musicians (one-on-one sessions are called Functional Integration, and group/audio lessons are called Awareness Through Movement). In the meantime, try not to grind away at exercises that trigger the curl—giving your nervous system novel, zero-tension ways to interact with the bass is usually much more productive than fighting it.

If you are in the UK let me know as I can give you the link to the charity I mentioned and I believe the musician's union has information about Feldenkrais, if it interests you.

A couple of videos follow, but there others on YouTube that might suit your situation more (I haven't done a massive search):


This is pianist but he explains that Feldenkrais can be helpful for all musicians...

 
Last edited:
Thank you for your reply @BloodMoon ! I am in the USA. I tried a completely different way I position my hand (I think it was the floating thumb technique instead of anchoring which is what I used to do) and my middle finger began acting normal for about 20 minutes but then went back to curling. I noticed for certain songs it curls up more.

I forgot to mention I have only been playing bass fingerstyle for a year, but with a pick for 14 years. I also have pain on my inner forearm where it meets my elbow. I completely ignore it and treat it like TMS. I'm not fearful of it. It starts to try and scare me when I do chin ups or when I stretch my arm out.
 
Interesting that you mention certain songs making it worse, and that changing your hand position temporarily made a difference.

If it were me, I'd be inclined to go back to using a pick for a while, particularly as you've been playing that way for 14 years, and then gradually reintroduce fingerstyle in baby steps. Perhaps start with some new, relatively simple songs where there isn't already an established association with the curling, and then very gradually work your way back to the songs that seem to trigger it.

This is the sort of gradual approach I've taken with my own mind-body/TMS recovery. I've gone from being bedridden for a total of over 18 months and housebound for many years to functioning pretty normally by comparison. I've found that taking the pressure off, very gradually rebuilding confidence and not feeling that I have to tackle everything head-on has been the most helpful and productive approach for my particular brain.

Anyway, just a thought, based on my own experience. I hope you get back to enjoying your bass playing!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top