How often rule out something structural?

Time2be

Well known member
Sorry, a maybe stupid question : I often wonder how you rule out something structural. One thing is that medical experts can contradict each other, or you get very different results. Another thing, and this is what bothers me at the moment, is that you can have the same symptoms periodically, you have ruled out something sinister four times and now the symptoms are there again. For me it is right now discomfort/mild pain in the stomach and pain in the back, between shoulder blades. My health anxiety shouts: another MRI to rule out pancreatic cancer. My calmer self says: not necessary, the same symptoms over the last 10 years, diagnostics (four times) says nothing to find besides a hernia and sometimes a mild gastritis. Which I know is nothing serious.
Have others the same problem? I know rationally that these symptoms are part of TMS, this year I am on a rollercoaster of symptoms: pelvic pain to dental pain, back to pelvic pain and now stomach/back pain.
 
Not a stupid question at all!

I can relate to this, although perhaps my experience has been slightly different.

In the early days of my symptoms, I was constantly looking for a structural or medical explanation. It wasn't necessarily because I thought, or was particularly fearful, that something malignant was going on. It was more that I wanted to understand what was causing the symptoms and, hopefully, find something that could be treated so I could get some relief and get on with my life without disabling pain and other symptoms.

I'd have a scan or investigation, but sometimes that wasn't enough. I'd then wonder whether a different type of scan or another test might reveal something the first one hadn't. I wanted to cover all the bases. A big part of my struggle was actually getting doctors to order all the blood tests and investigations I felt I needed, whether through the NHS or privately.

Interestingly, once I'd had the tests, I'd often switch off from the whole medical investigation process, even though the symptoms were still there. It was almost as though I'd tried my best, done the sensible thing and given up looking (usually until another new symptom had appeared and had persisted for a little while).

Over the years, though, as I experienced a myriad of different symptoms, I gradually began to recognise a pattern. There simply wasn't one structural disease or condition that could explain everything I was experiencing. The symptoms moved around, changed and appeared in seemingly unrelated parts of my body. Eventually, I came to realise that I wasn't going to find an "everything-under-the-sun-itis" diagnosis. TMS made much more sense of the overall picture.

I suppose I could have gone down the rabbit hole of thinking that some symptoms might be TMS, but others might be caused by a combination of different conditions, or that one particular symptom might be something else entirely and needed investigating separately. Thankfully, I didn't.

I wonder if there are a few questions worth asking yourself:
  • When you want another scan or investigation, whether a repeat or something new, what are you actually hoping to achieve? Is it reassurance that nothing sinister is happening, or are you hoping to find something treatable that could finally relieve your suffering?
  • What are you hoping another investigation will give you that the previous four investigations haven't?
  • If you genuinely think TMS is the most likely explanation, why doesn't that bring you some relief? Is it because the idea of TMS feels unsettling, perhaps because it's something you can't directly control? Is it the fear that something structural has been missed? Is it because you find the idea of TMS difficult to accept, or because the prospect of continuing to experience symptoms without a tangible medical solution feels frightening in itself?
  • Has worrying about your health become almost an automatic habit? Does every new sensation trigger the same cycle of fear, investigation and reassurance-seeking, even when previous investigations have been reassuring?
  • And perhaps a question that's a little more difficult: is it possible that focusing on your health and symptoms sometimes takes your attention away from other things going on in your life? Are there difficult emotions, perhaps anger, frustration, resentment, boredom or other things, that might be getting pushed into the background?
I'm not suggesting that any of these necessarily apply to you, but I think they're worth exploring.

I think understanding what is driving the fear, and what you hope another investigation will achieve, can sometimes be just as important as understanding the symptoms themselves.
 
@BloodMoon, thanks, very good questions! I have to think a bit about them. I can very much relate to your experience with some of my symptoms where I wanted to get at the root cause of it. And actually did in one case. In my situation now, the stomach and back pain are absolutely the same that I had for four or five times in the last 10 years. And I had a scan for being reassured that nothing malignant is going on. It is still basically this need for reassurance that drives me. If they say the scan is clear, I am sure the pain will subside in due time. It did always. I will think about the questions you posed. Is it an automatic habit? Yes, it is now.
 
It is still basically this need for reassurance that drives me. If they say the scan is clear, I am sure the pain will subside in due time. It did always.... Is it an automatic habit? Yes, it is now.
To go back to your original question, I don't think anyone can give you a definitive answer on how often to rule something out. Perhaps the question to keep returning to is: what does your "calmer self" (as you put it) tell you is sensible? And then trust that judgement.

TMS is a mechanism. (For me, remembering and thinking about it in this way has been a game changer.)

A symptom appears, fear takes over, and you check, research and seek reassurance through scans, tests or other means. Anxiety subsides temporarily, but the next symptom arrives and the cycle starts again.

Symptom, fear, checking, reassurance. Round and round it goes.

But what if you broke that cycle?

Instead of automatically reacting to every symptom, do what your "calmer self" considers sensible.

You need to gradually free yourself from the mechanism's grip and stop playing by its rules. Otherwise, you remain trapped on that same merry-go-round.
 
Last edited:
@BloodMoon, you have a very gentle way of posing important questions, thank you! I want to break the cycle, because otherwise it is the same merry-go-round, you are absolutely right. You also asked whether the attention to health issues take attention away from something else? Yes, there is something else, my parents, in their 90s, both have dementia. They are still living in their house with home care service, but my sister and I need to check every month. This is for me a 1300km travel. My sister 'only' 400km. They refused to go into a nursery home, but now we insist upon it. And my relationship to my parents was never very good. It cost me a lot of hours with psychotherapists to talk my childhood through. It is a very ambivalent situation. So, that's one thing.
You say: "You need to gradually free yourself from the mechanism ..." Yes, indeed, that is what I want to do. Little steps, I guess. I talked to a good friend who is a gastroenterologist and psychotherapist, he also said that no diagnostics is necessary. I had all the scans when I had this pain before. But anxiety doesn't listen to probability, even a little theoretical possibility instigates it. Rationally I know that, my irrational lizard brain needs to get this also .... So, little steps!
 
Hi @Time2be
On top of your excellent insights, and @BloodMoon's solid advice, I'd add one more question - which is to ask yourself how fast life is moving right now.
That's not how ACTUALLY fast but how fast it feels, and to ask yourself what you can do to slow down.
When find myself on the hamster wheel of problem solving, I notice that pattern. Sure, sometimes life is going fast, but sometimes my brain just wants it to seem like it's going fast because the faster I run, the faster I can get away from the "problem" at hand. So it likes to speed life up for me. It takes purposely focusing on slowing down even a little bit.
Sitting with a cup of coffee and if my mind is a whirl, a book. Even one page to re-focus.
A slow walk with no purpose at all but to gaze at the sky.
A bit of meditation, even 10 minutes (longer if you can manage).
Slow movements like 10 minutes of qui gong or something else enjoyable, again, with no purpose.
You may have things you really enjoy doing for yourself in this department too.
While I do these things I remind myself that thoughts are thoughts, not truths and just let those thoughts hangout there without offering them a purpose or a 'job' to do (like dialing the Dr.). Their presence is simply a mind habit. I treat anxiety the same way. Instead of a problem to solve, I recognize that the anxiety is simply a state that is. I notice how it comes and goes and how I'm perfectly fine when it's there or not there.
 
But anxiety doesn't listen to probability, even a little theoretical possibility instigates it. Rationally I know that, my irrational lizard brain needs to get this also.... So, little steps!
I guess the question though is what those little steps are going to be. Your lizard brain is simply the mechanism powering the merry-go-round, and you are 'Ms Rational'. So perhaps try something a little bit different... Imagine yourself, as 'Ms Rational', pulling down the lever to reduce the power and slow down the merry-go-round so you can get off. I'd suggest visualising this regularly. And it ties in with @Cactusflower's advice about the profound benefits of generally slowing down.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top