"If these thoughts (or symptoms) went quiet, what would I have to feel?"

BloodMoon

Beloved Grand Eagle
In this video titled 'The Real Problem with Overthinking' Dr Julie Smith (a psychologist) suggests to ask ourselves "If these thoughts went quiet, what would I have to feel?"

I've never heard it put quite like that before and I was thinking that it's something we could ask ourselves regarding mind-body symptoms, e.g. "If this pain went quiet, what would I have to feel?"

 
In this video titled 'The Real Problem with Overthinking' Dr Julie Smith (a psychologist) suggests to ask ourselves "If these thoughts went quiet, what would I have to feel?" I've never heard it put quite like that before and I was thinking that it's something we could ask ourselves regarding mind-body symptoms, e.g. "If this pain went quiet, what would I have to feel?"

In the video, she used another word for overthinking, namely, intellectualization. It is a well-recognized Freudian defense mechanism. ISTDP therapist Jon Frederickson has a great explanation of defense mechanisms. He says defense mechanisms are lies we tell ourselves to avoid emotional reality, and we use them because "[l]ife is hard, but psychological suffering can be unbearable". The way I would frame the question is this: What unbearable emotion(s) is my intellectualizing covering up?
 
I was thinking about our mind-body work and reading Rewire Your Mind, especially looking at all the "open tabs" we carry in our heads. It made me realize something specific about my own anxiety and pain loops.

In all my 68 years, I never once had to pump gas—Jeff always handled that. Since he’s been away, I’ve managed to dodge it by using various excuses, but I finally had to face it this week. And it made me look closely at what my mind is actually doing. I made an excuse that I had been hauling in some heavy outdoor things and I managed to escape having to pump the gas by myself.

Most of my daily, everyday tasks don't bother me at all; I can get through them fine. But my mind completely loops and obsesses around anticipation—especially when it's something new or something I fear. The big, heavy open tab that is constantly churning in the background is the worry about the pain itself: Where am I going to hurt today? If I pump gas, is my right side going to flare up? If I have to lift my dog to go to the groomer, as happened this morning, is it going to create more pain? And it did, even before I lifted the dog in the car.

It’s the relentless "what-if" machinery running in my head beforehand, anticipating and fearing the physical flare-up, especially if I have to do something outside of my home. I've always worried about preparing for upcoming events, even those there's nothing really to prepare for. I worry weeks and days prior before and I just can't seem to stop myself from worrying. IF I was to stop the worrying, as the video talked about, what emotions would I feel? I don't have a clue.
 
@Patty Cakes
Perhaps the more useful question for you is not “What would I have to feel?” but “What is it like to be me in this situation?” That may reveal the feeling beneath the thoughts — the feeling that would be there if the thoughts were put on mute.

If, for example, the answer is fear, the task is not to argue with it or make it disappear, but to allow it to be there without being swept up in the protective and distractive thoughts circling around it. Feel the fear we don't want to experience.

Why? Because when we try to avoid an emotion, we can get caught up in thinking as a way of protecting ourselves from it. Allowing ourselves to feel it helps us learn that we can experience it without needing to escape it or make it go away.

My use of Steven Oats’s approach is specifically for breaking the habit of looping thoughts: when I notice the mind repeating the same or very similar frightening or catastrophizing sequence, I lengthen the out-breath and turn my attention back to what I am doing or on to something else. I do not need to analyse the thought, challenge it, or force it away. The aim is not to get rid of fear, but to stop giving the thinking loop my continued attention.
 
Last edited:
@Patty Cakes
Perhaps the more useful question for you is not “What would I have to feel?” but “What is it like to be me in this situation?” That may reveal the feeling beneath the thoughts — the feeling that would be there if the thoughts were put on mute.

If, for example, the answer is fear, the task is not to argue with it or make it disappear, but to allow it to be there without being swept up in the protective and distractive thoughts circling around it. Feel the fear we don't want to experience.

Why? Because when we try to avoid an emotion, we can get caught up in thinking as a way of protecting ourselves from it. Allowing ourselves to feel it helps us learn that we can experience it without needing to escape it or make it go away.

My use of Steven Oats’s approach is specifically for breaking the habit of looping thoughts: when I notice the mind repeating the same or very similar frightening or catastrophizing sequence, I lengthen the out-breath and turn my attention back to what I am doing or on to something else. I do not need to analyse the thought, challenge it, or force it away. The aim is not to get rid of fear, but to stop giving the thinking loop my continued attention.
I will try and ask myself that exact question. I guess what I really feel is fear of the pain, the fear of the flare up and the fear of uncertainty around the pain. The pain has gotten better but it is still definitely there.
 
I was thinking about our mind-body work and reading Rewire Your Mind, especially looking at all the "open tabs" we carry in our heads. It made me realize something specific about my own anxiety and pain loops.

In all my 68 years, I never once had to pump gas—Jeff always handled that. Since he’s been away, I’ve managed to dodge it by using various excuses, but I finally had to face it this week. And it made me look closely at what my mind is actually doing. I made an excuse that I had been hauling in some heavy outdoor things and I managed to escape having to pump the gas by myself.

Most of my daily, everyday tasks don't bother me at all; I can get through them fine. But my mind completely loops and obsesses around anticipation—especially when it's something new or something I fear. The big, heavy open tab that is constantly churning in the background is the worry about the pain itself: Where am I going to hurt today? If I pump gas, is my right side going to flare up? If I have to lift my dog to go to the groomer, as happened this morning, is it going to create more pain? And it did, even before I lifted the dog in the car.

It’s the relentless "what-if" machinery running in my head beforehand, anticipating and fearing the physical flare-up, especially if I have to do something outside of my home. I've always worried about preparing for upcoming events, even those there's nothing really to prepare for. I worry weeks and days prior before and I just can't seem to stop myself from worrying. IF I was to stop the worrying, as the video talked about, what emotions would I feel? I don't have a clue.

Hi Patty - honestly I think that this is a really good example of how the pain is taking centre stage when that shouldn't be the focus. I'm by no means saying you should feel a certain way about it, but the better question to me is how do you feel about having the pump gas irrespective of the pain, and how does never doing it make you feel? Is there frustration and anger at it? Is there frustration at your husband for never letting you do it? Is there embarrassment? Again, I'm not saying you should be embarrassed because you shouldn't (I'm just throwing out ways you could potentially feel), but I had a similar experience with bike riding and I was embarrassed (even if I didn't want to acknowledge it).

You say you are worrying about how it will impact the pain, and that's fair enough, but to me that's overriding and invalidating other potential emotions around it. It's basically (and I doubt this is true) insinuating to your brain that pumping the gas would be absolutely fine and be of no issue whatsoever if only this pain was gone. See how important that makes the pain? It makes it the enemy and the villain, something that's ruining your life to be rid of at all costs.

But what if the pain reflects other emotions around pumping gas for the first time? if so, it's not an enemy at all it's a messenger. That outlook makes it a lot easier to react better to the pain, as now it's trying to help you instead of punish you.

Hopefully that makes sense - but such a mindset shift can make a huge difference in recovery :)
 
Hi Patty - honestly I think that this is a really good example of how the pain is taking centre stage when that shouldn't be the focus. I'm by no means saying you should feel a certain way about it, but the better question to me is how do you feel about having the pump gas irrespective of the pain, and how does never doing it make you feel? Is there frustration and anger at it? Is there frustration at your husband for never letting you do it? Is there embarrassment? Again, I'm not saying you should be embarrassed because you shouldn't (I'm just throwing out ways you could potentially feel), but I had a similar experience with bike riding and I was embarrassed (even if I didn't want to acknowledge it).

You say you are worrying about how it will impact the pain, and that's fair enough, but to me that's overriding and invalidating other potential emotions around it. It's basically (and I doubt this is true) insinuating to your brain that pumping the gas would be absolutely fine and be of no issue whatsoever if only this pain was gone. See how important that makes the pain? It makes it the enemy and the villain, something that's ruining your life to be rid of at all costs.

But what if the pain reflects other emotions around pumping gas for the first time? if so, it's not an enemy at all it's a messenger. That outlook makes it a lot easier to react better to the pain, as now it's trying to help you instead of punish you.

Hopefully that makes sense - but such a mindset shift can make a huge difference in recovery :)
Hi Coach, I'm so sorry for the delay in responding—for some reason, I didn't get a notification for this one, so I completely missed it until now! Reading your reply gave me a lot to think about, especially after some things Blood Moon shared on another thread today. When I really dug down into why pumping gas feels so intimidating, I realized there's a huge layer of deep resentment underneath. Jeff always handled working and keeping gas in my car, while I managed pretty much everything else in the house, including working full time. I am now retired. Now that he's not here, having to add gas-pumping to my plate makes me feel so angry—like, in addition to everything else, I have to do this too?

At the same time, I want to be honest that holding the pump and actually doing it still brings up a very real, lingering fear that my left or right side is going to hurt even worse and I never know when or which side the pain may be on. Even though I can now see the emotional resentment behind it, my body is still reacting and the pain is still flaring, although not as bad. I know uncovering the emotional truth doesn't mean the physical pain magically vanishes overnight like some of the stories in the books suggest, but seeing what's driving it definitely helps me understand the loop better. Thank you for pushing me to look past the surface. I never realized the anger and resentment I actually had. I just always called it frustration.
 
Now that he's not here, having to add gas-pumping to my plate makes me feel so angry—like, in addition to everything else, I have to do this too?

Yes! A very powerful realisation and validation of your own feelings.

At the same time, I want to be honest that holding the pump and actually doing it still brings up a very real, lingering fear that my left or right side is going to hurt even worse and I never know when or which side the pain may be on.

That's good to note too - then. it's a case of lowering that fear and getting as close as you can to indifference on the basis that nothing is wrong with you. The symptoms are real, but they aren't reflective of damage, like you used to think they were. As such, your reaction to them was forged when you thought there was something wrong, but now you know there isn't, the reaction needs updating to reflect this new knowledge/understanding.
 
Yes! A very powerful realisation and validation of your own feelings.



That's good to note too - then. it's a case of lowering that fear and getting as close as you can to indifference on the basis that nothing is wrong with you. The symptoms are real, but they aren't reflective of damage, like you used to think they were. As such, your reaction to them was forged when you thought there was something wrong, but now you know there isn't, the reaction needs updating to reflect this new knowledge/understanding.
Thanks so much! I never realized how truly difficult this work is. I couldn't do it without all your and the Eagles support, through all of this. it's truly been eye opening.
 
When one talks about mind-body healing, chronic pain, and anxiety, the focus is looking at our emotions, perhaps anger, shame, fear. But as I've been doing this work, a brand-new word surfaced for me that feels like the real heartbeat of everything: Predictability.

Growing up, when my mother was hospitalized, our home life turned upside down. As a child, I didn't know if she was going to come home, was going to survive, or what my world would look like. It was a state of terrifying unpredictability.

During that chaos, my aunt—who lived in the same four-family house—became my anchor. Her door was always open. In a world that felt completely out of control, her home provided a calm, unwavering, reliable rhythm. It gave me predictability.

When I recently did an exercise imagining how to comfort my inner child, I realized she wasn't just asking for "safety"—she was begging for predictability.

I see that same pattern in my life today. When unexpected things happen—like an unannounced visit from a friend, or getting a sudden 8:00 AM phone call that Jeff has been rushed to the trauma center (as happened yesterday)—it completely shatters my routine. It sends my nervous system right back to my childhood, where things were uncertain, especially when my mother was in and out of hospitals.

This is why, today, my daily rituals matter so much. My morning tea, caring for my animals, feeding the birds, etc. They are my modern-day version of my aunt's open door. They are my sanctuary.

Yesterday, I put on music that I love (I haven't done that in a long time) and for the entire time the music was playing, I didn't feel any pain at all. Once I got up and moved around, it crept back, but that moment proved something vital: music can completely quiet my nervous system.

The big question I have is--can predictability counteract uncertainty?

This leaves me wondering, how does building and honoring this predictability comport with the deep uncertainty that still terrifies me? I don't know what is going to happen with my husband. I don't know if he will ever be able to come home, or if he does, what kind of care he will need or how he will function. That unknowing is really heavy.

Can creating these pockets of predictable routine and joyful music in my daily life actually act as an anchor, in addition to that willow tree anchor, helping to counteract the paralyzing waves of uncertainty and worry I have? Can my daily rituals protect my nervous system from getting swept away by the things I cannot control?

I am learning that I don't have to fix or predict the outside world. But by building a predictable harbor inside my own home—anchored by my routines, my animals, and the music I love—maybe I can give my mind and body the steady ground they need to weather whatever comes next.
 
@Patty Cakes
I love the word you found—predictability feels like the missing piece beneath “safety”. Safety can sound abstract, but predictability is something the body can actually feel: the open door, the familiar rhythm, the morning tea, the animals, the birds, the music. These are not small comforts; they are signals to your nervous system that say, “Right now, you are here. Right now, there is a rhythm. You are not alone in the unknown.”

I don’t think predictability cancels uncertainty. Rather, it gives you a stable place to stand while uncertainty moves around you. The waves may still come—especially when something as frightening as Jeff’s accident happens—but your habits and rituals can be the harbor. They cannot control the storm, but they can keep you from being swept completely away by it.

I also don't think the anchorage has to visibly or outwardly balance out the turmoil and uncertainty in our lives. We don't need to create an equal measure of calm to counter every measure of chaos. In fact, I think a little anchorage can go a very long way. Sometimes it is just one familiar ritual, one moment of connection, one small thing that remains constant amid everything that feels unpredictable. Its significance isn't necessarily in how much space it takes up in our lives, but in the sense of steadiness it gives us. Even the smallest point of familiarity can offer something for us to hold on to when so much else feels beyond our control.

You can’t eliminate uncertainty. But you can build enough steady, loving routines that, when uncertainty comes, you have an inner place to return to. You cannot predict what will happen with Jeff, but you can keep creating moments that remind your body it is still held, still cared for, and not entirely at the mercy of fear. You are already learning how to stay with yourself through the unknown.

Your aunt didn’t remove the chaos in your childhood. She gave you one reliable, loving constant within it. That may be exactly what you’re doing now for your inner child: creating an “open door” inside your own life. Your routines, your animals, your music, your willow tree—these become evidence that there is still steadiness, care, and beauty available even when the future is unclear.

And your experience with music feels especially important. For those moments, your body wasn’t bracing, scanning, or trying to solve the future. The music changed the feeling in your body—it gave your nervous system something safe and familiar to rest in. That doesn’t mean the pain or fear are “your fault,” or that music is a cure. It means your body is capable of shifting, even briefly, out of alarm and into a different state. That is deeply hopeful.

Instead of asking, “Can I make the uncertainty go away?”—because you can’t—you can ask, “Can I build enough steadiness inside myself that uncertainty doesn’t completely take over?” You cannot control what happens next, but you can keep returning to the small, reliable anchors that help you stay connected to yourself: your tea, your animals, the birds, your music, and your willow tree. Those anchors remind you that, even in the middle of fear, you can find your way back to steadiness and care.
 
@Patty Cakes
I love the word you found—predictability feels like the missing piece beneath “safety”. Safety can sound abstract, but predictability is something the body can actually feel: the open door, the familiar rhythm, the morning tea, the animals, the birds, the music. These are not small comforts; they are signals to your nervous system that say, “Right now, you are here. Right now, there is a rhythm. You are not alone in the unknown.”

I don’t think predictability cancels uncertainty. Rather, it gives you a stable place to stand while uncertainty moves around you. The waves may still come—especially when something as frightening as Jeff’s accident happens—but your habits and rituals can be the harbor. They cannot control the storm, but they can keep you from being swept completely away by it.

I also don't think the anchorage has to visibly or outwardly balance out the turmoil and uncertainty in our lives. We don't need to create an equal measure of calm to counter every measure of chaos. In fact, I think a little anchorage can go a very long way. Sometimes it is just one familiar ritual, one moment of connection, one small thing that remains constant amid everything that feels unpredictable. Its significance isn't necessarily in how much space it takes up in our lives, but in the sense of steadiness it gives us. Even the smallest point of familiarity can offer something for us to hold on to when so much else feels beyond our control.

You can’t eliminate uncertainty. But you can build enough steady, loving routines that, when uncertainty comes, you have an inner place to return to. You cannot predict what will happen with Jeff, but you can keep creating moments that remind your body it is still held, still cared for, and not entirely at the mercy of fear. You are already learning how to stay with yourself through the unknown.

Your aunt didn’t remove the chaos in your childhood. She gave you one reliable, loving constant within it. That may be exactly what you’re doing now for your inner child: creating an “open door” inside your own life. Your routines, your animals, your music, your willow tree—these become evidence that there is still steadiness, care, and beauty available even when the future is unclear.

And your experience with music feels especially important. For those moments, your body wasn’t bracing, scanning, or trying to solve the future. The music changed the feeling in your body—it gave your nervous system something safe and familiar to rest in. That doesn’t mean the pain or fear are “your fault,” or that music is a cure. It means your body is capable of shifting, even briefly, out of alarm and into a different state. That is deeply hopeful.

Instead of asking, “Can I make the uncertainty go away?”—because you can’t—you can ask, “Can I build enough steadiness inside myself that uncertainty doesn’t completely take over?” You cannot control what happens next, but you can keep returning to the small, reliable anchors that help you stay connected to yourself: your tea, your animals, the birds, your music, and your willow tree. Those anchors remind you that, even in the middle of fear, you can find your way back to steadiness and care.
Thank you so much for your kind words and for putting things into such clear perspective for me. What you wrote really struck a chord with me, especially about how my aunt provided that loving constant when I was young.

I always wanted to be just like her. She was a strong, determined, loving, compassionate woman. Reading your words made me realize that in a way, she is passing her strength right back onto me. By creating these small, predictable comforts every day, I get to offer that same steadfast presence to the frightened little child inside—and carry forward her legacy of love to myself.

It means more than I can say to have your understanding and insight.
 
Dear Bloodmoon,

I hadn't looked at my old scrapbook and my memories of my aunt in decades, but I took it out today and ended up crying buckets of tears—good tears, healing tears.

Reading through it all brought back that profound wave of love, and it struck a nerve that made me want to reach out to you.

I just wanted to tell you how important your words and your understanding have been to me. What you share goes so much deeper than surface things. It hits right at my heart and soul.

Your messages give me that exact same feeling of profound safety, warmth, and unconditional acceptance that I used to find with my aunt, when I was little. You see the real me, and you make me feel truly understood, just like she did.

I know you have such a deep understanding of how people feel, and that natural empathy shines through in everything you write. Thank you for being such a rare and steady light.
 
Aww, @Patty Cakes – thank you! 🩷 That's such a beautiful thing to say, and I'm genuinely touched by your words. I'm just so glad you find what I write helpful. I think it helps that we've been through some similar life experiences and are around the same age, as there's perhaps an understanding there that doesn't always need explaining.

I was actually just about to post something for you that I thought you might appreciate. It's from a new book I've been eagerly awaiting, which has just been published today and downloaded to my Kindle.

It's a little 'safety/comfort' meditation:

Rest into Safety
  1. Find a position where you can fully let go, reclined on a couch or bed with your head, neck and back supported.
  2. Feel the seat under you holding your weight. Give yourself a little time to sink in.
  3. Think of someone or something that brings warmth – I was thinking of your aunt – and imagine them sitting quietly beside you.
  4. Sense your breath moving in its own time. With each exhale, allow somewhere in your body to soften just a little more.
  5. Stay here until your body feels ready for the smallest next step.
(From 'Somatic Healing: Soothe Your Nervous System with Body-first Therapy: Over 100 Guided Exercises' by Emily Winter.)

I thought of you when I read this, particularly the part about imagining someone who brings you that feeling of warmth and safety. I hope it brings you a little comfort, too 🌸
 
Back
Top